Why So Many CLM Implementations Fail—And What We Haven’t Learned from the Icertis Lawsuit

Thaija Dickerson, M.B.A., M.S.

April 14, 2025

Why So Many CLM Implementations Fail—And What We Haven’t Learned from the Icertis Lawsuit

The 2021 lawsuit between Change Healthcare and Icertis wasn’t just a vendor dispute—it was a case study in how CLM (Contract Lifecycle Management) implementations can go very wrong.

75% of deliverables needed rework.
Over $3 million in losses.
And still—many organizations are repeating the same mistakes.

Too often, CLMs are sold as the magic bullet, but without a strategic plan, they turn into expensive super repositories with a sprinkle of AI—full of documents but devoid of insight.

Here’s what many still miss:

1. CLM features ≠ CLM value
You can have all the right features and still fail if they’re not aligned to real commercial outcomes.

2. Implementation ≠ Enablement
Without training, documentation, and change management, your users won’t adopt the system—and ROI will stall.

3. AI ≠ ROI without clean, structured data
AI on top of disorganized contract data is like building a mansion on sand. You need AI-ready contract data first.

The result?
Many CLMs become digital filing cabinets instead of value-generating tools.

If your CLM feels more like storage than strategy—it’s not too late.
You don’t need more features. You need a new approach.

If you don’t want your CLM to turn into just another place to store contracts, let’s talk.

#CLM #ContractManagement #CLMStrategy #AI #DigitalTransformation #10XContractValue

<All Posts